*formatted for desktop viewing only*
“— In short, must a song
always be a song!”
— Charles Ives
Holding Pattern over Providence
For new things one necessarily chooses new words. Call our adepts spiritists, our teaching spiritism, our reading books of spirits. Forget the past — one cannot know everything — the spirit loses memories to become itself. The veil is the return to bodily life.
Divine angels, you expected, predictably enough, these corrections which I implore you to make in the manuscript. Mad as a tripod, and difficult, I dictate nothing more, all else will derive from actors’ games. Play Les Scythes as if it were La Philosophie dans le boudoir, and Les Scythes will have an effect of cold, of nonsense, of fabric cut against the grain.
We have only volume two; how can we be responsible
for ratcheting our faults beyond the limit of the past? How can we
profit
from experience acquired in forgetfulness? There are gaps
or things missed out in this account. To make up
for something forgotten or for a lapse or oversight that cost him
his life.
I can’t remember whom I should warn. I have not forgotten the guide, kind sir who at each new level of
existence
surveys the mistakes committed, judges the given position as just,
makes amends for what has leaked out along the way. He looks
for proofs analogous to those we learned before, and asks the
spirits
who are his superiors for help in this new task, intuition,
piecework I’ll do in my own good time.
The Antediluvian World
Was such a catastrophe possible? The testimony of the sea
is unequivocally yes; catastrophes are continual, commonplace, and
require
no great preparation or anterior warning. Geologically speaking,
we are the last of an incalculable number of vast changes,
continents sunk under the ocean while new lands rise on both sides
of it.
A loud explosion was heard, and immense columns of boiling mud,
mixed with lapilli, of the size of nuts, were projected from the
mountain;
on the following days the rain fell in torrents. Testimony of the flora and fauna is likewise abundant and
irrefutable.
The banana is seedless. Have you never wondered at this? The
deluge,
when it comes, is total. The Pacific coast possesses no papaw,
no linden or basswood, no locust trees, no cherry tree large enough
for timber,
no gum trees, no sorrel tree, nor kalmia; no persimmon trees,
not a holly, only one ash that may be called a timber tree, no
catalpa or
sassafras, not a single elm or hackberry, not a mulberry,
not a hickory, or a beech, or a true chestnut.Our deluge is not the first; our actual race of man
is not the first. “The earth,” says Cosmos, “presses downward,
but the igneous parts tend upward.” The sun hangs suspended in
between,
hidden behind a crooked mountain at night.Isinglass
It has often, through the course of life, been my lot
to meet with such friends, and I have built upon their love,
and felt secure in their friendship, who when adversity came,
then would the scene of my boyhood return
upon my imagination, and the thought force itself upon me,
that I had again, while searching for crystal, found
and been struggling only for isinglass.What is the rule? What kind of stone is crystal?At length, by the help of tufts of grass which grew here and there
at the jetting of rocks, I, with great exertions, reached
the top, and, creeping carefully to the edge of the precipice,
seized the prize. But what was my disappointment, when I found
that I had climbed the steep, and risked my life, to attain
a piece of isinglass!Rule: learn to read and talk so correctly as to have no occasion to repeat or change your words. Think how a sentence would look, if written or printed as a careless person reads it; or how a person would appear in walking, if he moved so halting, and backward and forward, as many do in reading.
I now commenced my search in earnest, but still, as before,
fortune seemed, in an uncommon manner, to avoid me. There is but
an hour or so left, said I, throwing my eyes upward to the sun;
even now, the bottom of the quarry begins to grow dusky,
and, if not soon successful, I shall have to give up the search,
and make the best of my way to the city. I was again commencing
my exertions, when my eye rested on the highest point of a rocky
hill,
which, by the continued labors of the quarrymen, approached
nearly to the form of a cone. There, on the summit, and at the very
edge
of one of its steepest sides, lay something sparkling in the sun.
Ha!
thought I, there is something to reward an afternoon’s labor; it
must,
by its brilliancy, be a noble piece of crystal.What is the rule? Will the reader look at his hearers as much as he can, and yet read correctly? Is it not also necessary, and more than good manners, that those to whom the reading is addressed, should look at the reader, and attend well to what he says? I always console myself with the idea, that I have, at least, gained some knowledge of those that surround me; but though I always return with an increase of experience, it is mingled with disappointment. Natural history has been called the science of observation; and as an observer, every man has it in his power to become a naturalist in a greater or lesser degree. Every detached object of this science — every crystal, or stone — not only excites interest, when we have acquired, by careful investigation, a knowledge of its properties, but leads the mind forward to new subjects of curiosity. Isinglass: its principal use is for clarifying wines and other liquids. It generally appears as leaf, book, and long and short staple; or pipe, lump, and honeycomb. It has valuable agglutinating properties; dissolving in two parts alcohol it forms a diamond cement, the solution cooling to a white, opaque, hard solid. To increase its availability, the raw material is sorted, soaked in water till it becomes flexible and then trimmed; the sheets are passed between steel rollers, which reduce them to the thickness of paper; it then appears as a transparent ribbon, shot like watered silk. The ribbon is dried, and, if necessary, cut into strips. The material is obtained from the swimming bladder or “sound” of fish, the most valuable being species of sturgeon: the seuruga (Acipenser stellatus), the sterlet (Acipenser ruthenus), the ossétr (Acipenser güldenstädtii).
Winter Night
The subject is a scene on Central Park West and 73rd Street. My notions at the time were those of a “purist,” which accounts for the dreamy mood as well as the stark character of the work. The idea about subject matter is that it should help to typify, uniquely. The Blue Inn: neither an inn nor is it blue. Figures are incidentals. The weird procession of flagellants chanting mournfully in the night may be seldom seen, less so by visitors, but does it translate to an idea? No apologies. The night really posed for the painting. And we look up at this blue barrier as if it were some fragment of a wall which anciently bounded the earth in that direction.
The Intellectual Life
One word presents itself before others: simplify. You have a difficult voyage; you must lie down; is there a law to govern the necessary estrangement, pushing through the crowd, cutting of teeth — is there a road away from the village, and toward the problem at hand? One can always reveal the soul; fingers draw the curtain apart; a card game is in progress; but one mustn’t hitch dissimilar animals, one needn’t solve the wrong problems. The game, though visible, is nonetheless an argument for solitude. Cooperate with your peers; cultivate necessary relations; yet conserve your fair share of necessary action. Maintain above all an interior silence. Reduce your rate of expenditure. Conserve the flux of thought, chattering mind.
“It is not necessary to believe,” writes Mme. de B. in her journal,
“that the best and sole use of time is calm, sustained, and
ordered.
Agitation is a useful state of mind; corresponding as it does
to our actual state of being. One mustn’t think that work is more
than a supplement of possibilities to the achievement of one’s
being.”
De la Lecture
Tell me why you like A, B, C . . . Perception? I am afraid of the category “no,” even in the case of a response. To take a biological example: let the student make a description of a tree. Of a tree that cannot be confounded with any other. Of the type of tree without reference to any other tree. Now count the words that obscure the tree. Break the ambition of those discrete individuals who might wish to be confused. And if some lover such as we have heard this dialogue of one, believe that the reader will see it. The tree. Ideal republic: A, B, or C . . .
Failures
A failure broke the monotonous uniformity — a few exercises, short easy sentences, and we begin anew: open the door, admit we’re done. They mean to expel him from the school. I regret to hear it.
A tree has roots, a trunk, and stems, and each branch or bough has twigs; and these bear leaves, and some have fruit, as pears and plums, and figs.
What is perfection? Deprived of all but innocence, the elephant took the child up with his trunk, and placed it on his back, and never afterward obeyed another master. Other models follow, examples for practice. Sentences lengthen, always of course the unassisted production of the pupil himself, so what use these suggestions, dictations?
I fix my eyes on different objects, and soon perceive I have the
power
of losing and recovering them; and that I can at pleasure destroy
and renew this beautiful part of my existence.
Long Weekend
Consulting an international code of hydrography, we find:
“There is an uncharted obstruction in the channel. You should
proceed
with caution.” But the pyramidal obstruction is in fact man-made,
painted white with the enthusiastic idealism of one who builds
bricks on rocks to make the rocks more visible.
Pure shapes are, let us suppose, more practical; resistant to the
elements
and also the pure white resembles salt, or surf; in theory
there are reasons for every decision, but not so here
where so many obstructions exist one cannot possibly chart them
all.
Tell me how to pass — how to weave — you are clear of danger —
are you clear of all danger? — The undulating niddy-noddy
and rotating umbrella swift are in classically experienced hands
or old hands at least, these problems in the channel having been
drawn
out of the chart chest in the hall; where beside the octant
and creased slightly by the brass speaking trumpet
we find the aforementioned code, a document of practical
contradictions: You should proceed with great caution —
you should proceed without assistance — there is not sufficient
depth of water — there is sufficient depth of water — I have no
radar — are you equipped with radar?
Nota Bene
Simple suggestions, when directed at one’s self, can render powerful effects; viz., the amateur violinist, told he is professional, plays (while asleep) to suit. At a certain time, always the same one, I wake up and prepare a breakfast of boiled eggs and tea. On the fifth day of the month, which I always keep holy, in order to pass the rest of the day in meditation and prayer, I ascended the high hills of B — . Landscapes consisting of parts and members, or even very simple and uniform ones, can be variously arranged, their sense remains unaltered. Drowning hills leaves islands, contours unchanged though now only visible theoretically. Instruments play louder and louder to reach places that used to resound with whispers. But that’s re-use, something let’s assume one must champion over destruction. What was here is carted away in pieces, what they bring is enough to continue a tradition of what’s left. Which is continuity. Failure to continue is, well, the schoolbook says: John was buried here. This single sentence may be read twenty-four different ways, four of which will be questions. 1) The farmer, Pete, ardently loves the beautiful shepherdess, Mary. I ascended the high hills of B — , in order to pass the rest of the day in meditation and prayer, on the fifth day of the month, which I always keep holy. From the result of my own personal observation, I am fully convinced that there has formerly been a population much more numerous than exists here at present. It appears that: 2) During the night a band of robbers entered the village, plundered the houses, and killed the inhabitants; or 3) Leaving it entirely to the imagination we descend into the depths of “time beyond,” and trace these remains back six hundred years, from the ages of trees, and other data. (N.B. — The longest questions ought generally to be placed last.) 4) Contented and thankful, after having visited here, we return to our retired and peaceful habitation. The little bleak farm, sad and affecting in its lone and extreme simplicity, smiled when, in inverted order, various birds rose singing, from highest to lowest, in a chorus of forms, over the solitude. In order to pass the rest of the day in meditation and prayer, I ascended the high hills of B — , on the fifth day of the month, which I always keep holy. Thy skies are as blue, thy groves are as sweet, thy fields are as verdant, thy crags are as wild, as they were in those early days, when, compelled by violent persecution to quit his native land, a rabbi wandered over barren wastes and dreary deserts. At last, fatigued and nearly exhausted, he came to this village. In order to pass the rest of the day in meditation and prayer, on the fifth day of the month, which I always keep holy, I ascended the high hills of B — . Early one summer morning, before the family was stirring, an old clock, that, without giving its owner any cause of complaint, had stood for fifty years in a farmer’s kitchen, suddenly stopped. I ascended the high hills of B — , on the fifth day of the month, which I always keep holy, in order to pass the rest of the day in meditation and prayer.
The Minor Poets
One knows nothing of their life. The sea has taken all. I have no boat, and no companions. Only one thing is left: my love for you.
One follows hunches. One debates the established rules. In effect, one completes — in this latter half of a divided century — an anthology of ten volumes of three hundred pages each, all in small type.
O Penelope, it’s only chance that brought you unlucky Ulysses; looking at your careful writing on this package I feel the weight of my own torments. You accuse me of indolence. I only want to listen to your account of suffering.
The Total Solar Eclipse
Our sun is one of the ordinary stars. It may even be below
the average. But if we would understand the other stars, we must
complete a study of our own. Several of its most interesting
portions
are invisible; our knowledge incomplete until these portions
understood;
the interior, for example, is invisible. The spherical body which
is popularly
called “sun” is bounded by an opaque photosphere — and this which
we see
is insignificant. The sun-lit sky prevents effective search by
everyday methods.
The sun is black. Apparatus should be set up, adjusted, tested
and used; and time should be available for retrial. The point-image
of a distant star includes all the details, and must be studied
whole,
whereas the sun can only be studied in detail. It is not too much
to say that in many respects the sun is as enigmatical as ever.
The last word on the subject is by Professor P., who has deduced
the following interesting results: that the sun is primarily
invisible except
at eclipse; that its superlatively interesting features constitute
an insignificant part of its mass; that our knowledge of the sun
is based entirely on a study of peripherals; that eccentricity is
possible
but inexplicable; that four telescopes, making three photographic
exposures each,
secure negative images of one hundred and sixty-two stars; that
such images
are recognizable and known; that stars in such images are entirely
black;
or otherwise invisible; that what is probable does not seem to
account
for the observed perturbations.
Austria Lower to Bisectrix
An entire life devoted to pairs: works published in two parts; sin understood both actual and original; honor and condemnation; and death, still in the enjoyment of these two dignities.
But rage continues to completion. “I’d be a butterfly,” he offered, but then: “Oh, no, we never mention her.” Other light and graceful songs are forgotten for mismanagement, anxiety, financial difficulties, ill health. The citadel stands empty. Letters received there, though affected in manner, show a real mastery of style emphasizing idiomatic elements.
He lived at the foot of the mountain, and was famous
as a thief and a swindler. The object of the story
is to establish the connection between these attributes
and their incarnate representations. The interpretation is
expounded
in two treatises, the one on the motion of the earth,
the other on the fixity of the stars.Cf: The well known case recorded in Des Indes à la planète Mars in which the automatist produced writing in an unknown character, which purported to be the Martian language. The hand and arm are insensible; she guides her hand not by sight but by some special extension of the muscular sense. A patient in an attack of hysteria, to whom appeals are made in vain, can sometimes be induced to answer in writing questions addressed directly to the hand.
Now we find the answers to two mysteries: one, making
more or less a loud noise, bearing an inscription in monkish Latin,
a name or distich on its function; and the other, a monster
more or less goblin-like, howling, with many forms and more
haunts, stalking the country where nurses frighten children with
its name.
Glass, Stained
Theoretically this is no less effectually to be done by the “primitive” than by the “realist”: two artificial masses, lighted by a lamp and viewed by a telescope from the outside, conspire to pull together. Efforts at abstraction lead to universal application. Meaninglessness? A condition, imaginary — a sort of “Mrs. Harris” or “Mrs. Grundy,” who typifies the disciplinary control of the conventional, the tyrannical pressure of the opinion of neighbors. Where it is lost, conscious attempts to restore it lead to absurd misplacements; consider humble, humor, even honor. Or feverish changes: captured by insurgent peasants; re-taken by the Duke; deprived of privileges; resolved on a pacific policy and attracting foreign capital; sharing, to the full, the national desire for expansion. And at their command, of transparent colors: blue, green, purple or amethystine, amber, brown, and rose; and of opaque colors, white, black, red, blue, yellow, green, and orange.
Some Knowledge
Shall I now speak something of my sentiments concerning poesy? It must be confessed or supposed at least, that there are seasons when it is hard to suppress the exuberant flow of lofty sentiments. But when a subject is proposed to your thoughts, consider whether it be knowable at all, or no; and then whether it be not above the reach of your inquiry; and consider again whether the matter be worthy of your inquiry at all; and then how far (according to age, station, capacity, your chief design and end). Query, cui bono? The glory of God? Little tricks and deceits, by sliding in or leaving out such words as change the situation should be abandoned and renounced by all honest searchers after truth. To what purpose? For your own advantage? Is it not enough to determine the truth, or to forbid any proposition the title “axiom” — ? What may be enough is just indifference. A warm zeal ought never be employed. I believe there is a God, and that obedience is due to him from every reasonable creature; this I am most fully assured of, because I have the strongest evidence, since it is the plain dictate both of reason and of revelation. Some effects are found out by their causes, and some causes by their effects. Yet I would lay down this caution: No man is obliged to learn and know everything; yet all persons are under some obligation.
Kite
Granting our connection, it is nonetheless subject to review and reform; relatio est fictio juris — relation is a fiction of the law — yet the laws seem secure, confident in their simplicity and arrogantly ambiguous when need be. The kite flies higher, or is it just further away? The relationship we crave seems stubbornly impossible; thus go hopes based on pictures. One sorry look cannot reverse this situation. One is born in a direction, top-down, you might say; it is the global trend, large arrows, that cause today’s frustration.
The development of a science is only the discovery of what is already in existence; in an incredibly short time the introduction of the principles of this system to your consciousness will be appreciated and accepted. Is speed really the issue? Of course one can tabulate and manipulate ad infinitum, one can meditate even while walking in the street. One should accomplish something of importance every minute spent — in other words — in every sixty seconds’ worth of distance run, spun out, burned into one’s mind and hands. You must be your own schoolmaster; you must recognize that you are always in need; and you must be ready to practice any severities against yourself in order to gain this, unsolitary, end.
Now I lift my eyes and see the universe full of magnificent promise. The kite is dangling. What I think of as l’histoire (nf) is more apparent — a predilection to shorthand self-taught, shaded eyes in the sun, a certain laziness over a cup of tea, gameness for a new exertion. The flight is consistent, even though she feigns to contravene her own laws. When a man becomes aware of this aimlessness, then descends on him the misery of disillusionment. Must one have a fixed purpose, sufficient determination, to accomplish a thing? Isn’t light a natural electricity? In what units does one measure activity? Should we make the supreme effort to master this system, or alter our own to conform to it? One learns much by analogy.
Evidently bigger and further would change things. Conditions could improve. The compilation, computation, and condensation of facts might help. Still I believe there is no such thing as inaction. You have resources now at your command that would save you 70% of the time and effort you would normally devote: are you using them? If you are not, won’t you take us into your confidence? Can’t you let us make everything just as easy as possible? I assure you it (your confidence) will be respected and appreciated. Dear Sir, and Dear Madam, are decidedly stiff and formal; they haven’t the warmth typical of real life; they are not applicable to personal convictions; and it is with a feeling of genuine anxiety that I again write you regarding our long-overdue accounting. Yes, you have the idea exactly. I have found it pays in the saving of energy, in the wear and tear of this business life, to mix in a little “sentiment,” just for lubricant, you know. My hands are burning. I am dangling by a string. I have no special desire to tell this in detail — the point is this — General Garcia is dead, but there are other Garcias. He is wanted in every city, town, and village. In every office, shop, and factory. He is needed, and needed badly — may you never fail to find “Garcia.”
You have at your hand a new experience with which to meet
situations that confront you. Not the kite, which fell into the sea
some time ago, or the shiny trail of string racing over the sand;
not the crazy
undulations of a thing at rest, or soothing determination of one
in motion; the system is based on the use of old habits,
instead of requiring the formation of hundreds of new ones.
This is what removes it from memory, and establishes it as
principle: that all unnecessary effort has been removed. Dramatic
stories,
which make the nerves tense and suspend the breath, help one to
forget
the restrictions on one’s capabilities — and repetition, like a
tonic,
has a relaxing effect. These are the means of developing
inattention. An endless copying of the words and thoughts of
others,
the law of growth, the law of unfoldment, the law of relaxation
and repetition . . . Perfection is the goal to be reached. Dictate
to yourself. Perfect work. All is from within, out. Herein is
direction. A declarative sentence is followed by a period.We know you will like this work. Some will like it more than others. You will all like it in time. There is little for you to do. Do that as well as you can. We all like to do this work.
Portrait
Expressing oneself fluidly but also willingly
pushing aside old campy rules of comportment
and demarcation; also new concerns like health care
and environmental litigation — what’s left is a place setting,
arranged exquisitely for seven courses beginning near mid-summer’s
night
and lasting nigh our reentry into the thick urban atmosphere
looking salty and exhausted; sunburned and cheerful;
no one project has occupied us fully in your absence,
but with your return our focus will readjust and you, you, you
would, and may, easily and gracefully express the right thought
and to you therefore this work is respectfully dedicated.*
He is seated with a book in his left hand,
possibly his own poem on the landscape which may be seen
through the window on the right; his costume and headgear
seem very unbecoming. He appears to be laughing at himself.
Standing on a hill in the landscape outside is an unidentified
woman
in a green satin dress; her fair hair falls over her bare
shoulders, an open book is propped against a skull;
with her is a man in a fur cloak with a white collar,
his right hand is open as if to grasp something.
He has an air of dignity which reminds one of a Roman emperor.
A woman is in the room, lying nude on a white couch;
she betrays the utmost delight in voluptuous sensuality.
Her fair hair falls over her bare shoulders,
an open book is propped against a skull.
He is on her lap and clutches at a corner of her cloak.
She is in the act of removing the scarf in which
he is wound. He lies naked on the couch
trying to catch the floating fabric in his hands.*
But there are so many clichés about looking like a Roman emperor. Anyone aiming to reinforce image with identity, a kind of psychological rime-riche, should take note: pitfalls in marble are many. Better in coin, or a bronze as some god or allegorical figure. This sort of ambiguity is exemplary: “Female bust, wrongly called Berenice, as there is no resemblance with the coins bearing her image and superscription.” The lips are covered with a thin layer of copper. The hair dressed high is kept back by a double plait. The goddess Artemis (vengeful) is suggested, but the bust is most likely a portrait . . .
“She was a golden brown presence, burned by the Tuscan sun and with a golden glint in her warm brown hair. She wore a large round coral brooch and when she talked, I thought her voice came from this brooch.”
*
It is one of those moments when you wonder at the building
or at the Building of the Wonder, when even a minor castle
distracts for an eternal-type moment, there on the first level
over the sea, which is naturally shining, and the southern sky
is from this perspective also marvelous — such observations
to be packed away tightly in barrels, perhaps, and stored
in one of the available towers (little imagination has been devoted
to their functional resurrection). And now at a second level
we find thirty candles and as many monks, all outdoors and exposed
to the salty air on which we are about to remark when, from
underground,
our own gate emerges clearly marked with international symbols
meaning
come in, please, for water, a newspaper, and our eternal delight —
or is it banishment that will be pronounced from this, final level,
the spacious apartments of perhaps an abbot? Or other
ecclesiastical
prince? Our lady is ambiguous but steadfast in her encouragement
to use and enjoy these, our natural facilities.
The Book as a Planet
The earth moves through empty space around the sun. The old idea
of the earth resting on, or being supported by something, is
erroneous.
The earth rests on nothing.A book or other inanimate object placed on a support will remain at
rest
until something or somebody moves it. If the book be thrown up
through the air,
it ought to keep on moving upward forever, because it has no more
power
to stop moving than to begin to move. Our earth moves through empty space around the sun, and must continue so moving.(Space is not absolutely empty, but is everywhere filled with a very
tenuous
substance called ether. Wherever the telescope reveals the presence
of stars,
or the eye reads words on a page, we must believe the ether also
extends.)

